How to Pray When God Feels Absent: The Christian Tradition on Spiritual Dryness
Desert Tradition • Hesychast Teaching • St. Silouan the Athonite
How to Pray When God Feels Absent: The Christian Tradition on Spiritual Dryness
Every serious Christian encounters seasons when prayer feels empty and God feels far away. The tradition has a name for this experience — and a complete teaching on what it means, why it happens, and what to do in it.
At a Glance
- What It Is
- The experience of prayer feeling barren, God feeling absent, and the consolation that once accompanied faith disappearing — sometimes for months or years
- What the Tradition Says
- Dryness is normal, expected, and in many cases a sign of growth rather than failure — the withdrawal of consolation so the soul learns to seek God rather than His gifts
- Key Teachers
- Desert Fathers; St. Silouan the Athonite; Gregory Palamas; Amma Syncletica; Theophan the Recluse
- The Famous Saying
- "Keep your mind in hell, and despair not" — Christ to St. Silouan: face the truth of your condition honestly, and do not despair of mercy
- What to Do
- Pray anyway — short, honest prayers offered in the dryness itself, without pretending a warmth you do not feel
- What Not to Do
- Quit; interpret dryness as abandonment; fill the silence with spiritual busyness; demand consolation as evidence of God's presence
You have been praying. You have been faithful — as faithful as you know how to be. And somewhere along the way the warmth disappeared. Prayer that once felt alive now feels mechanical. God, who once seemed near, now seems to have stepped back. You go through the motions because you believe you should, but the belief itself feels thin and distant. You wonder if you have done something wrong, if you have drifted further from God than you realized, if the early days of faith were simply enthusiasm that has now run its natural course.
The Eastern Christian tradition has a name for what you are experiencing. It has been naming it, describing it, and teaching people how to survive it since the 4th century. It was written about by the Desert Fathers in Egypt, by the hesychast masters of Byzantium, by the great Russian elders of the 19th century, and by saints whose lives make it clear they knew this darkness from the inside. Their testimony, across seventeen centuries, is consistent: what you are experiencing is not failure. It is not abandonment. It is a stage — one of the most important and most difficult stages — of a spiritual life that is going deeper than it has gone before.
This article draws on that testimony. It explains what spiritual dryness is, why it happens, what St. Silouan the Athonite's famous saying means, and — most practically — how to pray in the dryness itself. The prayers that follow are from The Way of Mystical Christian Prayer — a collection of Desert Father and hesychast prayers that includes a full section on surrender, dryness, and perseverance, each prayer with its source and instructions for use.
What Spiritual Dryness Actually Is
The word "dryness" is the tradition's own — xerasia in Greek, sikhot in some Slavic texts — and it describes a specific spiritual condition, not a general psychological state. Spiritual dryness is the experience of prayer becoming barren: the feeling that the words you are saying are not going anywhere, that God is not present to receive them, that the attention and the desire that once accompanied prayer have dried up and left a mechanical habit in their place.
It is distinct from several things it is sometimes confused with. It is not the same as laziness, though laziness can produce a superficially similar experience. It is not the same as depression, though depression and dryness can occur together and can be difficult to distinguish. It is not the same as doubt — a person in spiritual dryness typically continues to believe; they simply do not feel the presence of the One they believe in. And it is not the same as sin-caused distance, though the tradition acknowledges that genuine unfaithfulness can create a real estrangement that requires repentance and return.
Genuine spiritual dryness — the kind the tradition teaches on — occurs specifically in the lives of people who are already praying seriously, already making genuine efforts to live faithfully, already committed to the practice of the interior life. It is not what you experience when you haven't prayed in weeks. It is what you experience when you have been praying faithfully and the consolation suddenly stops.
Before assuming you are in the spiritual dryness the tradition describes, it is worth asking honestly: Have I been faithful in practice, or have I gradually drifted and am calling the resulting emptiness "dryness"? The tradition distinguishes between the two — not to shame but to point toward different responses. If genuine neglect has crept in, the response is return and repentance. If you have been faithful and the consolation has simply disappeared, you are in the territory this article describes.
Part II
Why It Happens: The Tradition's Explanation
The Eastern Christian tradition offers a coherent explanation for why spiritual dryness happens — one that is more honest and more psychologically accurate than the vague reassurances that often substitute for real teaching on this subject.
The Withdrawal of Consolation Is Not Abandonment
The first and most important thing the tradition teaches: the felt absence of God is not His actual absence. Theophan the Recluse — the great 19th-century Russian bishop whose letters on prayer remain among the most practically useful texts in the hesychast tradition — is explicit: God does not leave. What is withdrawn is the felt presence of God — the warmth, the consolation, the sense of nearness — not the presence itself. This distinction is not a consoling fiction. It is a precise theological observation about the difference between God's ontological presence (which is unconditional and continuous) and His experiential presence (which varies for reasons that serve the soul's formation).
Weaning: The Soul Is Being Formed Toward Greater Maturity
Amma Syncletica, whose image of smoke before fire we have already met, explains why consolation is withdrawn in terms of spiritual maturity. The soul that began its prayer life motivated by the good feelings that accompanied prayer — the warmth, the sense of meaning, the spiritual enthusiasm — must eventually be weaned from those motivations if it is to grow into something deeper. A person who prays because prayer feels good is, in a sense, still praying for themselves. A person who continues to pray when prayer feels like nothing is beginning to pray for God.
This weaning is uncomfortable. It is meant to be. The tradition uses the image of a parent who gradually reduces the easy satisfactions provided to a growing child, not from cruelty but because the child's development requires it. Continued provision of immediate consolation would produce a spiritual infant — someone who can only pray when it feels good. The withdrawal of consolation produces, in those who endure it, something the tradition values far more: a prayer that does not depend on reward.
Purification: The Dryness Is Doing Work
Diadochos of Photike, one of the most psychologically penetrating writers in the Philokalia, adds a third explanation. The period of dryness is not merely passive — it is not simply waiting for consolation to return. It is actively purifying the soul of the subtle self-seeking that accompanies even sincere prayer. While the dryness continues and the person continues to pray faithfully through it, something is being stripped away: the desire for spiritual credentials, the investment in one's own spiritual progress, the subtle pride that accumulates in a person who has been praying seriously for years. The darkness is not empty. It is working.
Part III
St. Silouan and "Keep Your Mind in Hell, and Despair Not"
Of all the sayings in the Eastern Christian tradition about darkness and dryness, none is more famous — or more frequently misunderstood — than the one associated with St. Silouan the Athonite: Keep your mind in hell, and despair not.
Silouan Antonov was born in 1866 in Russia and came to Mount Athos as a young man. For years he was tormented by what he later described as spiritual abandonment — the complete withdrawal of the sense of God's presence. In his writings, preserved and edited by his disciple Archimandrite Sophrony Sakharov, he describes this period with an honesty that is almost shocking in a saint's memoir: he felt he had been forgotten by God, that his prayers went nowhere, that the grace he had briefly experienced in his early monastic life had been entirely withdrawn.
It was in this darkness that he received — or understood himself to receive — a word from Christ: Keep your mind in hell, and despair not.
The saying has two parts, and both are essential. The first — keep your mind in hell — means: do not look away from the truth of your condition. Do not perform a spiritual equanimity you do not have. Do not dress up your darkness in theological language that lets you avoid experiencing it. The hell referred to is not damnation but the honest confrontation with what is actually present: the dryness, the absence, the fear that it will never lift, the suspicion that something in you is irreparably broken. Face it. Stay in it. Do not use spiritual practices as a way of escaping the truth of your interior condition.
The second part — despair not — is not a contradiction of the first but its completion. The honesty the first command requires is only bearable because of what the second command promises: that the darkness you are facing honestly is not the final word. Mercy exists. It is available. The One you are facing your darkness before is not indifferent to it. Keep your eyes open, and do not lose hope.
This saying became the compass of Silouan's prayer life for the rest of his decades on Athos. It was not a formula that removed the darkness — the darkness continued, and he continued to pray through it. But it gave him a posture to maintain in the darkness: truthfulness without despair, honesty without hopelessness. These are the two things the tradition requires of a person in spiritual dryness, and they are also the two things that are hardest to hold together.
The first temptation is to pretend: to perform a spiritual wellbeing you do not have, to tell God you are fine when you are not, to avoid the honest confrontation with the darkness because the honesty feels dangerous. The second temptation is to despair: to interpret the darkness as final, to conclude that you are beyond mercy, to stop praying because prayer seems pointless. Silouan's word names both temptations and refuses both. Honesty, without despair. This is the posture.
I do not hide this from You.
I remain before You
even in silence.
If You are hidden,
teach me to wait.
Part IV
Dryness, the Dark Night, and the Eastern Parallel
Western Christians who have encountered the literature of the spiritual life will recognize spiritual dryness under the name St. John of the Cross gave it: the dark night of the soul. John's analysis — the dark night of the senses (the withdrawal of sensory consolation in prayer) followed by the dark night of the spirit (the deeper withdrawal of spiritual consolation itself) — describes the same phenomenon the Eastern tradition addresses, using a different theological framework.
The Eastern parallel is found most precisely in Gregory Palamas's schema of purification, illumination, and union — the three stages of the hesychast journey. The period of purification, which precedes illumination, is characterized by exactly the experience this article describes: the stripping away of consolation, the intensification of the awareness of one's own weakness, the apparent withdrawal of the felt presence of God. Palamas, like John of the Cross, is explicit: this is not the journey going wrong. It is the journey going deeper than it has gone before.
Where the Eastern and Western traditions describe the same experience, they differ slightly in emphasis. The Western dark night literature tends to focus on the soul's passive experience of the stripping — what is happening to the person. The Eastern tradition tends to focus more on what is required of the person in response — the continued faithful practice, the honest prayer, the perseverance. Both emphases are needed. The darkness is real and it does have a passive quality; the person cannot simply will their way out of it. But the response of continued faithful prayer is not passive, and the tradition is insistent that it matters.
The honest answer: the tradition does not give a schedule. Silouan's darkness lasted years. John of the Cross describes the dark night as potentially very extended. The Desert Fathers spoke of periods of aridity that lasted seasons without relief. What the tradition does say consistently is that the darkness does not last forever — and that what emerges from it, in those who endure it faithfully, is a quality of trust and a depth of prayer that could not have been produced any other way. The duration is God's business. The faithfulness during the duration is yours.
Part V
How to Pray in the Dryness
The tradition's guidance on how to pray in seasons of dryness is specific. It does not consist of techniques for generating feeling or methods for ending the dryness faster. It consists of honest, faithful practices that honor the dryness rather than fighting it.
Pray with Honesty About the Dryness
The first instruction from virtually every teacher in the tradition: do not pretend. If prayer feels empty, tell God it feels empty. If God feels absent, say so — directly, to Him. The Desert Fathers were deeply suspicious of prayer that was more eloquent than the person praying actually was. A brief, honest acknowledgment of the actual condition is worth more than an hour of performed piety. The prayers of surrender and dryness in the Eastern tradition are almost uniformly short and almost uniformly honest: Lord, I feel nothing. I remain anyway.
Use Shorter, Not Longer Prayers
In dryness, elaborate prayer is often counterproductive — it requires an engagement of the imagination and the will that the dryness has specifically depleted. The tradition's consistent recommendation is to shorten, not lengthen, the prayer in dry seasons. The Jesus Prayer, or the brief prayers of the Desert Fathers, are specifically adapted for this condition: short enough to be prayed when nothing else is available, honest enough to mean something even when nothing feels meaningful.
Keep the Ordinary Practice
Perhaps the most important practical instruction: do not abandon the ordinary practice of prayer simply because it has stopped producing the results you are looking for. The Desert Fathers spoke of this as sitting in the cell — maintaining the external discipline of prayer even when the interior dimension has gone quiet. The Philokalia teachers are consistent: the practice kept faithfully through dryness is the very means by which the dryness is endured and eventually resolved. To stop because prayer produces nothing is to remove the one thing that is keeping you in the relationship.
Offer the Emptiness Itself
Several teachers in the tradition suggest something more radical: the offering of the emptiness itself to God as prayer. Not as a technique but as an act of trust — saying, in effect: this is what I have. I have no warmth, no consolation, no sense of Your presence. I offer You the nothing. Receive it. This posture, while it cannot be manufactured by will, sometimes arises naturally in those who have been in the dryness long enough that pretense has become impossible. When it does, the tradition treats it as among the most genuine forms of prayer: stripped of everything, the soul is simply before God with nothing to offer but itself.
I remain anyway.
I do not measure Your presence
by sensation or clarity.
Teach me to stay
when prayer feels empty.
Part VI
What Not to Do in Spiritual Dryness
The tradition is as specific about what not to do in dryness as it is about what to do. Several responses to dryness are consistently identified as counterproductive or actively harmful.
Do Not Interpret the Dryness as Evidence of Abandonment
The feeling that God has left is not evidence that God has left. The tradition is emphatic on this. Theophan the Recluse writes with some urgency to correspondents who have concluded from their dryness that they are abandoned: the conclusion is wrong, the consolation has been withdrawn for reasons that serve the soul, and the feeling of abandonment is itself part of what is being purified. To interpret the feeling as fact is to allow the emotional state to override seventeen centuries of consistent testimony to the contrary.
Do Not Fill the Silence with Spiritual Busyness
One of the most common responses to dryness is to compensate for the lack of interior prayer with an increase in exterior religious activity — more services attended, more books read, more spiritual projects undertaken. The tradition does not oppose any of these things in themselves. But when they are used specifically as a way of avoiding the silence and the emptiness, they are counterproductive. The dryness is asking for something — a quality of honest, patient waiting — and spiritual busyness is a sophisticated way of refusing to provide it.
Do Not Abandon the Practice Entirely
The most dangerous response to dryness is simply stopping. The reasoning feels logical: if prayer produces nothing, why continue? The tradition's answer is not sentimental: because the practice of faithful, fruitless prayer is itself the formation. The soul that continues to pray when prayer produces nothing is developing a quality of trust and commitment that cannot be developed any other way. To quit is to miss precisely the formation the dryness was there to provide.
Do Not Demand a Timeline
The anxiety about how long the dryness will last — whether it will ever end, whether this is now simply the permanent condition — is a specific temptation the tradition warns against. Demanding to know the duration is a subtle way of setting a condition on faithfulness: I will continue to pray if this ends by a certain point. The tradition requires an unconditional faithfulness: I will continue to pray because God is God and prayer is my appropriate response to Him, regardless of how long the darkness lasts.
I do not fill it.
I remain anyway.
Do with this silence
what You will.
Part VII
Why Perseverance Matters More Than Intensity
The Desert Fathers had a phrase that runs through the Apophthegmata in dozens of variations: stay in your cell. We have already encountered it — but in the context of dryness, it carries a specific weight. The cell here is not just a physical space. It is the practice of prayer itself: the commitment to return to it daily, to remain in it when it produces nothing, to inhabit it without demanding that it reward you for being there.
The tradition consistently values perseverance over intensity. A person who prays briefly and faithfully every day for decades is considered, in this teaching, to be further along the path than a person who prays with great intensity for periods and then abandons the practice when the intensity fails. Intensity is partly a function of feeling; it fluctuates with emotional state, with the season of the spiritual life, with physical health, with circumstances. Perseverance is a function of will, commitment, and eventually of something deeper than either — the settled orientation of the soul toward God that the tradition calls the prayer of the heart.
Abba Poemen, who appears more frequently in the Apophthegmata than any other Desert Father, was once asked what the greatest virtue was. He said: Perseverance. Not the greatest spiritual experience, not the deepest prayer, not the most heroic ascesis — perseverance. The faithfulness that keeps returning, keeps showing up, keeps praying the same short honest prayer day after day even when the day produces nothing remarkable. This is what the tradition considers the foundation of everything else.
Part VIII
Five Prayers from the Tradition for This Season
The following prayers are drawn from Part V of The Way of Mystical Christian Prayer — the section on surrender and detachment. They were prayed by the Desert Fathers, the hesychast monastics, and the early Christian ascetics in exactly the conditions this article describes. Use them as they were used: slowly, honestly, without demanding that they feel like anything.
Not enthusiasm,
but faithfulness.
Teach me to walk steadily
even when progress is unseen.
what You are doing.
Still, I consent.
Receive my trust
even without clarity.
Not in clarity,
not in resolution.
Remain with me
as my only ground.
Eastern Christian Prayer Cards for Your Parish
Handcrafted prayer cards for personal devotion, adult faith formation, or bulk parish orders — including cards featuring the Desert Fathers and their prayers for the difficult seasons of the spiritual life.
Browse Prayer Cards →Questions About Spiritual Dryness and Praying Through Absence
The Darkness Is Not the End of the Story
The Eastern Christian tradition has been naming spiritual dryness, describing it accurately, and teaching people how to pray through it for seventeen centuries. Its testimony is consistent: the dryness is real, it is painful, and it is doing important work. The soul that endures it faithfully — praying honestly through the emptiness, refusing both pretense and despair, keeping the ordinary practice without demanding that it produce results — is being formed into something that comfortable, consolation-rich prayer could never produce.
Stay. Pray honestly. Do not despair. The prayers below are what the saints prayed in the dark. They are available to you now.
Get The Way of Mystical Christian Prayer on Amazon →As an Amazon Associate, The Eastern Church earns from qualifying purchases.
