Blessed Fulton Sheen and His Converts: Clare Boothe Luce, Louis Budenz and Bella Dodd

Fulton Sheen Clare Boothe Luce Louis Budenz Bella Dodd Converts Catholic Saints

Catholic Saints • New York • Washington • 1895 to 2026

Blessed Fulton Sheen and His Converts: Clare Boothe Luce, Louis Budenz and Bella Dodd

Fulton Sheen was a radio and television teacher with a very large audience, but much of his work was done one person at a time. His convert instructions brought a playwright, a congresswoman, a Communist editor and a Communist lawyer into the Catholic Church.

Fulton Sheen at a Glance

Born
May 8, 1895, El Paso, Illinois
Ordained
September 20, 1919, Diocese of Peoria
On air
The Catholic Hour (1930 to 1950); Life Is Worth Living (from 1952)
Bishop
Auxiliary bishop of New York (1951); Bishop of Rochester (1966 to 1969)
Died
December 9, 1979, New York, praying before the Blessed Sacrament
Venerable
June 28, 2012
Beatified
September 24, 2026, St. Louis, Missouri
Part I

From El Paso, Illinois, to the Doctoral Stage

Sources: Diocese of Peoria materials

Fulton John Sheen was born Peter John Sheen on May 8, 1895, in El Paso, Illinois, the eldest of four sons of Newton and Delia Sheen. He later took his mother’s maiden name, Fulton, as the name he used. As an infant he contracted tuberculosis and was not expected to thrive. The family later moved to Peoria, where he served as an altar boy at the Cathedral of Saint Mary, the same cathedral where his remains rest today.

He was a gifted student. He graduated from Spalding Institute in Peoria as class valedictorian in 1913 and entered Saint Viator College in Bourbonnais, Illinois, graduating in 1917. He then went to Saint Paul Seminary in Minnesota and was ordained a priest of the Diocese of Peoria on September 20, 1919, by Bishop Edmund Dunne.

His bishop sent him to further study, and the results were remarkable. He earned a doctorate in philosophy at the Catholic University of Leuven in Belgium in 1923, writing on contemporary philosophy and the idea of a finite God. He was the first American to win the Cardinal Mercier Prize for the best philosophical treatise. He went on to study at the Angelicum in Rome and spent time in England, where he taught theology and met the writer Ronald Knox.

In 1926 he returned to Peoria and was assigned to a poor parish, St. Patrick’s, a humbling posting for a man with his credentials. In 1928 he joined the faculty of the Catholic University of America in Washington, where he taught philosophy until 1950. It was there that he became a public figure.


Part II

The Catholic Hour and a Teacher’s Method

Sources: Diocese of Peoria materials

In 1930 Sheen began a weekly Sunday-night radio program, The Catholic Hour, on NBC, and he hosted it for about twenty years. At a time when many Americans knew Catholics mostly as an immigrant minority, Sheen spoke in clear, formal English about God, reason and the modern age. His audience was large and not limited to Catholics. Many listeners who wrote to him were not believers at all, and some, after listening for years, wrote to ask for instruction.

His approach combined argument with warmth. He did not argue with people to humiliate them. He wanted to show the way a mind could move from questions to faith. In 1940 he provided the voice-over commentary for an Easter Sunday Mass broadcast on an experimental television station, one of the first televised religious services in the country.

The radio years explain why the converts mattered to him. His public work reached millions, but conversion happened in private rooms and one person at a time. The famous names in this article were exceptions in a very long list of ordinary people he taught, whom history has not recorded.


Part III

Clare Boothe Luce

Sources: National Catholic Register, notable Sheen converts

Clare Boothe Luce was playwright, editor, ambassador and member of Congress, married to the publisher Henry Luce, and one of the best-known women in America. In January 1944 her only daughter, Ann Clare Brokaw, was killed in a car accident. Luce was devastated, and the loss opened a question she could not answer by herself.

According to the account in the National Catholic Register, she asked Sheen at a dinner why God would allow such a thing, and he spoke to her about sorrow as a door. She began what was reported to be about five months of instruction with him. She was received into the Catholic Church in 1946 at St. Patrick’s Cathedral in New York. Sheen later described her as having a mind like a rapier, which tells you what he thought of her as a student.

Her conversion mattered publicly because of who she was. A prominent, brilliant woman, married to the most powerful publisher in the country, had come to the Church through hard questions rather than comfort. The story shows something about Sheen’s method as well: he met her grief with an argument, not a platitude.

A different kind of convert was Henry Ford II, the grandson of the automaker. According to the National Catholic Register, he entered the Church in order to marry Anne McDonnell, a Catholic, and Sheen presided at the wedding in 1940. The article does not give a date for his reception or describe his instruction, so I only mention it as one of the best-known names on the list.


Part IV

Louis Budenz and Bella Dodd

Sources: Catholicism.org summary of Schmiesing; National Catholic Register, notable Sheen converts

Two of Sheen’s most dramatic converts came from the Communist Party. Louis Budenz had been raised Catholic and left the Church, joining the Communist Party USA in 1935. He became managing editor of its newspaper, the Daily Worker. According to one account, Sheen invited him to dinner around 1937 after Budenz had written an article criticizing him, and the two kept a relationship. About eight years later, Budenz asked Sheen for help returning to the Church. He, his wife Margaret and their three children entered the Church on October 10, 1945. He later taught economics at Notre Dame and testified before the FBI and congressional committees on Communist activity.

Bella Dodd was a lawyer and a leading figure in the Communist Party in New York, active in the teachers’ union. After she testified before the House Committee on Un-American Activities, she was challenged by Senator Howard McGrath to meet Sheen. The meeting took place at Sheen’s home. According to Sheen’s account, during a pause in their conversation he invited her to pray in the chapel. She wept, and in his words she was touched by grace. Sheen then instructed her and received her into the Church in 1952. She went on to teach law in Texas and later at St. John’s University in Brooklyn.

These two cases are important because they show the other side of the Sheen story. His anti-Communist preaching was very public, and critics have wondered whether it hardened people. Both of these conversions point the other way. The people he reached were the ones he argued with and then sat with, and the personal side of his work was as important as the public side. Some details of these conversions come from Sheen’s own later accounts and from admirers’ retellings, so they are best read as the Church’s tradition about the events rather than a neutral record.

Fulton Sheen prayer card
Prayer Card
Blessed Fulton Sheen Prayer Card
Teacher of the faith on air and in person. A card to carry for those who pray for converts.
View the Card →

Part V

Kreisler, Mann and a Television Star

Sources: National Catholic Register, notable Sheen converts

The violinist Fritz Kreisler was born in Vienna and baptized in childhood, but he had drifted from the faith for decades. After his wife’s suicide was brought to Sheen’s attention, Sheen met Kreisler through a neighbor and asked whether he and his wife would take instruction. The Kreislers had their marriage convalidated in 1947. Kreisler later adapted his Vienna March into a waltz that became the theme of Sheen’s television program.

Horace Mann, a former campaign manager for Herbert Hoover who had been accused of anti-Catholic activity against Al Smith in 1928, converted after listening to The Catholic Hour on the radio. Sheen then gave personal instruction to Mann and to his wife, who also entered the Church. Another convert, the New York literary agent Gertrude Algase, was born into a Jewish family and became Catholic after Sheen instructed her. She later represented Sheen and Cardinal Spellman and helped found the Alfred E. Smith Memorial Dinner.

In 1950 Sheen became national director of the Society for the Propagation of the Faith, a post that put him in charge of raising money for missions around the world. On May 28, 1951, Pope Pius XII named him an auxiliary bishop of New York, and he was consecrated in Rome on June 11 of that year. Eight months later, on February 12, 1952, Life Is Worth Living premiered on the DuMont television network. Filmed before a live audience at the Adelphi Theatre in New York, it showed Sheen in a black cape in front of a chalkboard. He was not paid for it. The program earned him an Emmy that year for most outstanding television personality, and it drew a vast audience.

A well-known 1952 magazine article credited Sheen with converting a list of famous people, including Heywood Broun, Clare Boothe Luce, Henry Ford II, Louis Budenz, Bella Dodd, Jo Mielziner and Fritz Kreisler. Not every claim on lists like this one can be checked in detail, so I have kept to the names with reliable accounts.


Part VI

Rochester, Death and Beatification

Sources: Diocese of Peoria materials; news coverage of the September 2026 beatification

In 1966 Pope Paul VI named Sheen Bishop of Rochester, New York. His time there was difficult. In 1967 he spoke strongly against American involvement in the Vietnam War, and his plan to hand over a parish building to a federal housing program fell through. He resigned the diocese in October 1969 and was given the title of archbishop of Newport, in Wales. The sources I found give two different dates for the resignation in October 1969, so I give only the month.

He wrote an autobiography, Treasure in Clay, which was published in 1980. In October 1979, Pope John Paul II visited St. Patrick’s Cathedral in New York and embraced him. Sheen died on December 9, 1979, in his private chapel in New York, aged 84, while praying before the Blessed Sacrament. He was buried in the crypt of the cathedral.

His cause for sainthood was opened by Bishop Daniel Jenky of Peoria in 2002, making him a Servant of God. On June 28, 2012, the Vatican recognized his heroic virtue, and he became Venerable. The cause then stalled for years over a dispute between the Diocese of Peoria and the Archdiocese of New York about the location of his remains. The archdiocese ended its resistance in June 2019, and on June 27, 2019, his remains were moved to St. Mary’s Cathedral in Peoria. On July 6, 2019, the Vatican approved a miracle attributed to his intercession: the 2010 recovery of a stillborn baby, James Fulton Engstrom.

A beatification set for December 2019 was postponed, and after a long delay it was rescheduled. On September 24, 2026, Fulton Sheen was beatified in St. Louis, Missouri, in a Mass attended by tens of thousands. Cardinal Luis Antonio Tagle presided on behalf of Pope Leo XIV. He is now Blessed Fulton Sheen.

It is fitting that a man who spent a lifetime on air is remembered above all for the individual conversations. The radio and television audience came for a performance. The Luces, the Budenzes and the Kreislers came in the end because someone was willing to sit with them.


Part VII

Timeline

Key dates
  • 1895: Born May 8 in El Paso, Illinois
  • 1919: Ordained September 20
  • 1930: Begins The Catholic Hour on NBC radio
  • 1945: Louis Budenz and his family enter the Church on October 10
  • 1946: Clare Boothe Luce is received at St. Patrick’s Cathedral
  • 1951: Named auxiliary bishop of New York on May 28
  • 1952: Life Is Worth Living begins February 12; Bella Dodd is received
  • 1966: Named Bishop of Rochester
  • 1979: Dies December 9 in New York
  • 2012: Declared Venerable June 28
  • 2019: Remains moved to Peoria; miracle approved July 6
  • 2026: Beatified September 24 in St. Louis
Prayer Card
Blessed Fulton Sheen Prayer Card
A pocket-size card for teachers, converts and anyone praying for a friend or relative to come to the faith.
View the Card →

One Person at a Time

Sheen’s greatest work happened in quiet rooms. His prayer card is a good companion for anyone praying for a friend or family member to come to the faith.

View the Fulton Sheen Prayer Card →

Frequently Asked Questions

Questions About Fulton Sheen

Accounts name Clare Boothe Luce, Louis Budenz, Bella Dodd, Henry Ford II, Fritz Kreisler and Heywood Broun among many others. Details are well documented for some, such as Luce and Budenz, and thinner for others.
She was received in 1946 at St. Patrick’s Cathedral in New York, after about five months of instruction with Sheen, following the 1944 death of her daughter.
He, his wife and their three children entered the Church on October 10, 1945. He had been editor of the Communist Daily Worker.
Not yet. He was declared Venerable on June 28, 2012, and was beatified on September 24, 2026, in St. Louis, so he is now Blessed. Canonization would require another approved miracle.
He died on December 9, 1979, in his private chapel in New York City, while praying before the Blessed Sacrament, at the age of 84.
The Eastern Church offers a Fulton Sheen prayer card in the prayer card collection, a good companion for anyone praying for a loved one to come to the faith.
A Servant of God

The work here is about bringing little-known saints to light, so their holiness can stand as an example for the whole world. If you'd like to support this mission, please consider purchasing a prayer card. This site was never just about the cards themselves — they're the way I help fund the research and documentation of saints both known and forgotten.

If buying a card to support the work isn't possible for you right now, could I ask you for something else instead? A prayer. I love our Heavenly Father, and I would only ask that you pray I might love Him more.

Lord Jesus Christ, Son of God, please have mercy on me, a horrible sinner.

Previous
Previous

Saint John Bosco in Paris, 1883: The Crowds, the Tickets and the Victor Hugo Question

Next
Next

Saint Macarius of Optina and Nikolai Gogol: The Writer Who Went to the Elder in 1850